Subscription Boxes for Men (my opinion)
About this video
McGoff shares his honest opinion that subscription boxes for menswear and accessories are not aligned with intentional buying practices. He opens a Gentleman’s Box and uses the contents to illustrate how subscription models lead to excess ownership, poor sizing fit, and items one wouldn’t deliberately purchase, arguing that the subscription model makes more sense for consumables than for durable goods like clothing and watches.
Key takeaways
- McGoff argues subscription boxes encourage excess consumption and ownership of items you don’t need or want, conflicting with intentional purchasing practices
- McGoff contends subscription boxes cannot accommodate individual preferences like proper sizing, making them problematic for personalized items like shoes, sunglasses, and socks
- McGoff recommends asking three questions before any purchase: Do I need it? Do I really want it? Can I afford it? He believes 99% of subscription boxes fail this test
- McGoff believes the subscription model makes sense for consumables like toilet paper and toothpaste, but not for durable goods that should last years
Episode details: published August 8, 2018 · 193K views · 10:21 long. Summary written by Self Growth Videos from the episode itself. The style advice summarized here is Brock McGoff’s own teaching and opinion, presented for education; product recommendations are his, not ours. Summaries are written by Self Growth Videos from each video itself.
← Previous: The BEST Shoes for Summer | Teddy Baldassarre, The Kavalier, Effortless Gent, The Style O.G. · Next: ASKET Haul & Try On | Wardrobe Essentials In Shorter Lengths →
All Brock McGoff videos · Brock McGoff profile · Brock McGoff (official site)
You Might Also Enjoy

Brock McGoff — Style as a System: Fit, Capsule Wardrobes, and Intentional Living
Explore →
14 Most Useful Purchases
Explore →
9 Things That Are NOT Worth Your Money
Explore →
14 ‘Buy Once Cry Once’ Products (Keep These Forever)
Explore →
2025 Holiday Gift Guide for Guys (17 GREAT Ideas)
Explore →