Editorial Reviews: Are They Worth It for Indie Authors?

About this video

Dale Roberts evaluates whether editorial reviews are worth it for indie authors. He defines them as professional third-party evaluations by reviewers, publications, award organizations, or paid services — distinct from customer reviews and star ratings — that live in Amazon’s Editorial Reviews section or are quoted in descriptions, back covers, press kits, and websites as credibility and social proof. Benefits he cites are a more professional edge when reader reviews are few, help persuading on-the-fence buyers, and quotable lines for listings, social graphics, and ad copy. The downside is cost and uneven quality: he says, as a creator claim, Kirkus can cost over $450 for a basic review with no guaranteed return, and some services deliver vague, skim-like feedback or exist only to exploit authors. From his own testing he recommends Readers’ Favorite as a truly free entry point, describes Ebook Fairs results as mixed, and describes Outstanding Creator Awards and Literary Titan as legitimate services that bundle reviews with award opportunities without participation trophies. He details how to actually use a review — Author Central, product description, website/media kit praise section, pitches, and ads — warns against guaranteed five-star services and other scams, notes award-bundling and his use of Book Award Pro, and advises beginners on a budget to skip editorial reviews until cover, blurb, keywords, and reader reviews are solid.

Key takeaways

• Editorial reviews are professional endorsements, not customer reviews: they add credibility and quotable proof but only matter if actively repurposed across Amazon, media kits, pitches, and ads
• Start free where possible: Roberts recommends Readers’ Favorite’s free option and warns paid prestige, such as Kirkus at over $450 in his account, does not guarantee return on investment
• Spot scams by red flags: guaranteed five-star reviews, no samples of prior work, no named reviewer/attribution, and generic filler that never mentions plot, structure, tone, or theme specifics
• Bundled review-plus-award services can add double value through a badge/credential, but legitimate ones will criticize or exclude weak books rather than hand out trophies
• Decision rule: beginners should fund cover, blurb, keywords, and reader reviews first; editorial reviews fit authors with a stable platform who are pursuing awards, media, or broader reach

Episode details: published May 8, 2025 · 9:12 long. Summary written by Self Growth Videos from the episode itself. Business results and any income figures mentioned are Dale L. Roberts’s own claims, shared for education — they are not typical or guaranteed.

← Previous: How to Write a Novel Using AI (Step by Step) · Next: Amazon KDP Just Made a Brutal Change →

All Dale L. Roberts videos · Dale L. Roberts profile · Dale L. Roberts on YouTube