I Tried $5 Etsy Ads for 60 days and This is What Happened | Do Etsy Ads Work | Etsy Ads Strategy

About this video

Dylan Jahraus explains why she dislikes Etsy Ads and shares the results of accidentally running them. She says she turned ads on unintentionally in July when copying listings, leaving a $5/day budget active for about 60 days on five new listings. She claims she spent $254 and generated $553 in ad revenue across 15 orders. Because those listings were priced for traction at roughly 50% margin instead of her usual 70-75%, she calculates only about $22.50 in profit remained after ad costs, and she saw no meaningful lift in average daily visits versus the two prior months. She argues paid traffic disappears when spending stops, while time invested in organic traffic from Pinterest, Facebook, and Instagram compounds for years. She says she only recommends ads briefly during an early ‘sprinting’ phase to get initial traction, not as a core strategy, and now focuses on ‘marathon’ profitability strategies after, by her account, building a shop doing $300,000-$400,000 per year.

Key takeaways

• Creator claims an accidental $5/day, 60-day Etsy Ads run cost $254, produced $553 in revenue from 15 orders, and left only about $22.50 profit on low-margin listings
• Check traffic lift, not just ad revenue: she reports no significant increase in average daily visits during the ad period versus the prior two months
• Paid traffic stops when spending stops, while organic work on Pinterest, Facebook, and Instagram can compound into lasting traffic
• If ads are used at all, she frames them as a short, sparing sprint-phase tool for early traction, not a long-term growth engine
• New listings copied from existing ones can accidentally inherit or trigger ad enrollment, so verify ad toggles after publishing

Episode details: published October 1, 2022 · 9:55 long. Summary written by Self Growth Videos from the episode itself. Business results and any income figures mentioned are Dylan Jahraus’s own claims, shared for education — they are not typical or guaranteed.

← Previous: Part 2: WHAT TO SELL ON ETSY | 25 Product Ideas for Etsy Sales Today | Products to Sell in 2023 · Next: 10 Ways to Grow FAST On Etsy as a Beginner ($0 to $1.3 M) What I Would Do If I Was Starting Over →

All Dylan Jahraus videos · Dylan Jahraus profile · Dylan Jahraus on YouTube