The BIGGEST Listing Hack for More Etsy Sales (Fix NOW)

About this video

The creator argues the biggest listing mistake is deleting listings or letting them go out of stock, because deletion loses the listing’s accumulated sales, revenue and traffic history and any remaining paid listing time. Instead, deactivate listings you no longer want to sell — deactivation preserves the history and lets you reactivate without a new 20-cent fee, though the renewal clock keeps running. The core hack is to repurpose an inactive or sold-out listing ‘shell’ with strong history for a new product: replace photos, description, pricing and variations, but keep as much of the old SEO as possible and choose a replacement product with overlapping SEO — for example, swapping a floral nursery decor listing for floral crib sheets or baby shower gifts. She cites one example listing with, by her account, $49,000 and 145 sales. For one-of-a-kind handmade items, keep the listing alive as made-to-order, disclaim that photos are examples, add a personalization box, and add photos of new variations; for vintage, backfill only with a very similar item and replace all photos. If a supplier runs out of stock, switch to pre-orders: extend the shipping profile, hide (don’t delete) the sold-out variation, and add a dated variation such as ’light pink ships 12/1,’ noting Etsy allows only one manual ship-date move, so build in a buffer. She claims this pre-order tactic made her an extra $20,000–$30,000 in one Q4, per her account. If an item will never return, substitute the closest product from another supplier while keeping the SEO identical.

Key takeaways

• Never delete a listing — you lose its sales, revenue and traffic history; deactivate it instead so the history is preserved.
• Repurpose inactive listing shells for new products, keeping as much of the old SEO as possible and choosing a replacement with overlapping keywords.
• For one-of-a-kind handmade items, keep selling made-to-order versions with a disclaimer that photos are examples and a personalization box for custom requests.
• When stock runs out, take pre-orders: extend the shipping profile, hide rather than delete the sold-out variation, and add a clearly dated shipping variation.
• If a product is gone for good, backfill the shell with the closest substitute from another supplier and update only photos and materially different details.

Episode details: published September 2, 2024 · 10:29 long. Summary written by Self Growth Videos from the episode itself. Business results and any income figures mentioned are Dylan Jahraus’s own claims, shared for education — they are not typical or guaranteed.

← Previous: The Best LASER Engraver To Buy in 2025? · Next: How To WIN on Etsy This HOLIDAY Season (Q4 Etsy Seller Tips) →

All Dylan Jahraus videos · Dylan Jahraus profile · Dylan Jahraus on YouTube