This is why Etsy sales are dropping fast

About this video

The creator argues Etsy sales are dropping because tactics that worked in 2020 and 2022 no longer work, and sellers who did not evolve after around 2022 saw sharp declines. She says she started her shop in 2016, forgot a listing with one photo and a couple of words, made a sale two months later, and eight weeks after adding strategy was making over $10,000 a month with just a few listings — something she says would never happen now. Her core fixes: choose a customer before a niche, because a niche says nothing about whether buyers have money or spend consistently (she contrasts dog owners spending $80 a week on premium fresh food with those buying the cheapest food at Walmart); win the value proposition, since buyers compare only the listing photo and price in a roughly 2-second comparison — she contrasts a personalized mom candle at $33 with a listing showing three candles at a 14.50 price point; build order velocity by driving warm traffic from Pinterest and Facebook groups, since Etsy ranks listings getting many orders per day above those getting one; and build a product mix designed to snowball — an evergreen loss leader plus mid-tier and premium products — rather than a general store or holiday listings with a 4-to-12-week lifespan. She claims over 555,000 visits to her shop from Pinterest and that the right 30 listings can make over $20,000 a month while a 1,000-listing shop may make nothing.

Key takeaways

• Choose a customer first, not a niche: target buyers with job security, discretionary income, and consistent spending habits rather than boxing yourself into a category.
• Buyers compare listings on photo and price alone in about a 2-second comparison; SEO gets you shown, but a weak value proposition loses the click and pushes you down in search.
• Order velocity drives ranking: she contrasts competitors getting 20 orders per day with a listing getting one order per day, and recommends driving warm traffic via Pinterest and Facebook groups to force early sales.
• She says she never uses a link in Facebook posts, credits Facebook for going from one order to $10,000 a month within eight weeks, and says her editor made 100 sales from one post within 24 hours.
• Build a snowballing product mix — an evergreen, mass-appeal loss leader plus mid-tier and premium items to raise average order value — instead of chasing holiday listings with a 4-to-12-week lifespan.

Episode details: published May 7, 2026 · 7:25 long. Summary written by Self Growth Videos from the episode itself. Business results and any income figures mentioned are Dylan Jahraus’s own claims, shared for education — they are not typical or guaranteed.

← Previous: The ONLY Way To Etsy Success in 2026… · Next: How To Start Selling on Etsy in 2026 (Beginners Guide for $6,891/Mo) 💸 →

All Dylan Jahraus videos · Dylan Jahraus profile · Dylan Jahraus on YouTube