This is why everyone is quitting Etsy (and what YOU should do about it...)

About this video

Dylan argues Etsy is not dying or too saturated, and frames a 9-to-5 as the riskier long-term option because wages, retirement, and job security are outside the worker’s control. Comparing side hustles, she presents Etsy as the most tangible low-startup-cost route to getting an offer in front of buyers on day one, versus capital-heavy Amazon FBA/dropshipping, affiliate marketing, or day trading. Citing figures she says were the most recent published at filming, she claims active sellers fell slightly from 7.5 million to 7.47 million (2021 to 2022) while active buyers were 95 million, versus 9.7 million sellers on Amazon and 18 million on eBay (creator-cited figures); her point is that Etsy is saturated with bad listings, not good ones, so sellers with a real strategy can still stand out. She says Etsy customers are more patient about handmade/custom turnaround than Amazon customers, and that Etsy lets sellers set their own return policies, which Etsy supports. Traffic is her other argument: Etsy traffic is cheap or free with SEO and social media, whereas a standalone website takes years of skill or paid work to look trustworthy and converts worse with strangers. Driving 100 sales from social media to an Etsy shop, especially quickly, can cement Etsy search ranking in a way the same sales would not move Google ranking for a website. She concedes sellers should not stay only on Etsy forever — use it to build the business and brand quickly, then scale — and presents competition as a force that improves products and customer experience. A closing testimonial claims a student went from $696 the month before the program to $4,149 and 133 orders the month after joining (testimonial claim).

Key takeaways

• The saturation argument is countered with creator-cited figures: about 7.47 million sellers versus 95 million active buyers, and many listings are low quality
• Etsy is pitched as the lowest-overhead, fastest-to-first-buyer starting platform compared with Amazon FBA, dropshipping, affiliate marketing, or day trading
• Etsy sellers control their own policies (including no returns) and Etsy customers are described as more patient with custom/handmade turnaround
• Free organic traffic via SEO and social media is the model; sales velocity driven into Etsy can lock in search ranking
• Use Etsy as the starting platform to build brand and customers, then expand beyond it for the long game

Episode details: published May 13, 2024 · 9:22 long. Summary written by Self Growth Videos from the episode itself. Business results and any income figures mentioned are Dylan Jahraus’s own claims, shared for education — they are not typical or guaranteed.

← Previous: 5 NEW TRENDS For 2025 That Will Make You Rich on Etsy 🚀 · Next: First 60 Days Selling on Etsy REALISTIC Results (What To Expect) →

All Dylan Jahraus videos · Dylan Jahraus profile · Dylan Jahraus on YouTube