Are Spier & Mackay Shirts High Quality? (Value Review)

About this video

The Gazette team provides a comprehensive, unsponsored review of Spier & Mackay shirts after spending over $1,600 testing their products for 18 months. They examine the brand’s history, pricing strategy, fabric quality, construction, sizing options, and customer service, offering detailed analysis of what works well and what doesn’t for different buyers.

Key takeaways

• The Gazette team argues that Spier & Mackay offers exceptional value for price-conscious buyers, with ready-to-wear shirts ranging from $39-$88 (often available on sale for $19), using a direct-to-consumer model to keep costs low
• The Gazette team recommends sticking with button-down collar styles, as their other collar options suffer from tip-curling issues over time, whereas button-down collars remain crisp throughout the day
• The Gazette team notes that sizing consistency is problematic—identical sizes between different shirts may fit differently depending on fabric type and weight, making purchases risky and returns difficult on sale items
• The Gazette team found that Spier & Mackay’s customer service is slow and unhelpful, with lengthy response times and reluctance to accommodate customer requests, making the purchase experience frustrating despite low prices

Episode details: published February 11, 2022 · 74K views · 29:10 long. Summary written by Self Growth Videos from the episode itself. The style guidance summarized here is the Gentleman’s Gazette team’s own teaching and opinion, presented for education; product recommendations are theirs, not ours. Summaries are written by Self Growth Videos from each video itself.

← Previous: Business Card Cases: Definitive Guide for Professional Style · Next: “Budget” Cashmere: Myth or Magic? (Uniqlo, Everlane, & More) →

All Gentleman’s Gazette videos · Gentleman’s Gazette profile · Gentleman’s Gazette (official site)