Cutting Apart 50 Years of Allen Edmonds Shoes (Value Review)

About this video

The Gentleman’s Gazette team dissects four modern Allen Edmonds shoes and two vintage pairs from the 1970s to investigate claims that quality has deteriorated over time. By comparing construction methods, materials, and workmanship across decades, they evaluate whether Allen Edmonds remains a reliable investment for classic menswear.

Key takeaways

• The Gazette team finds that Allen Edmonds construction has remained remarkably consistent across five decades, using the same nails, welting techniques, and assembly methods throughout, contrary to quality-decline claims
• The Gazette team observes that modern Allen Edmonds shoes now include sock liners and foam padding under the insole, but these additions don’t compromise the quality leather sole underneath and can be removed if desired
• The Gazette team notes that one modern loafer model (Sanibel) appears to have different construction than other current styles, suggesting possible outsourcing or different manufacturing, despite being marked ‘handcrafted in the USA’
• The Gazette team identifies that vintage Allen Edmonds featured more refined details like leather heel caps and embossed elastic bands, while modern versions use thermoplastic heel caps, representing a simplification rather than a degradation of quality
• The Gazette team concludes that despite minor changes in materials and last shapes, Allen Edmonds shoes remain a solid quality investment compared to most mass-produced footwear, which has declined significantly since the 1970s

Episode details: published February 18, 2022 · 57K views · 48:56 long. Summary written by Self Growth Videos from the episode itself. The style guidance summarized here is the Gentleman’s Gazette team’s own teaching and opinion, presented for education; product recommendations are theirs, not ours. Summaries are written by Self Growth Videos from each video itself.

← Previous: “Budget” Cashmere: Myth or Magic? (Uniqlo, Everlane, & More) · Next: Reward Yourself! 8 Buys to Celebrate Milestones & Success →

All Gentleman’s Gazette videos · Gentleman’s Gazette profile · Gentleman’s Gazette (official site)