Thoughts About Earning Knowledge
About this video
McPhee discusses his philosophy on knowledge-sharing and training, arguing that instructors should freely give information rather than making trainees ’earn’ it through trial and error. He contrasts his early Army experience with his current teaching approach, advocating for transparency so people can make informed decisions and progress efficiently.
Key takeaways
- McPhee argues that withholding knowledge under the guise of ’earning’ it is counterproductive and reflects outdated military culture
- McPhee believes people are inherently intelligent and will make sound decisions when given complete information about processes and outcomes
- McPhee contends that in fast-moving tactical environments, delaying knowledge transfer wastes time and puts people at a disadvantage
Episode details: published September 11, 2017 · 21.1K views · 2:05 long. Summary written by Self Growth Videos from the episode itself. McPhee’s service stories are his own accounts, attributed to him — not independently verified. His tactical and firearms instruction is his doctrine, presented as his teaching — not legal or safety advice from Self Growth Videos.
← Previous: Range Audio: “Shooting Faster” John “Shrek” McPhee · Next: How To Fit The Condom Holster →
All John McPhee videos · John McPhee profile · SOB Tactical (official site)
You Might Also Enjoy

Unveiling Leadership in Chaos | The Lesson You May Have Missed
Explore →
Shitty Bosses - A take by John "Shrek" McPhee
Explore →
#84 SOB Podcast - Season 5 - Episode 1 - Spencer Pratt
Explore →
John McPhee on Why You Should Never Compromise Who You Are
Explore →
Life Update + A Lot of Gratitude
Explore →