Fighter Pilot Reacts To SU-57 vs F-18 Top Gun Maverick

About this video

Max, a former F-15E and F-16 Thunderbirds pilot, analyzes the dogfight scene between an F/A-18 Super Hornet and a Su-57 from Top Gun: Maverick using a flight simulator. He breaks down tactical decisions, weapon systems, and maneuvering characteristics while testing whether Tom Cruise’s character was correct that the F-18 cannot dogfight the Su-57. Max argues that pilot proficiency matters more than aircraft superiority in visual range combat, though he acknowledges the Su-57’s advantages in thrust vectoring and one-circle fights.

Key takeaways

• Max argues that within visual range combat, pilot proficiency becomes more important than aircraft capability, stating ‘it’s not the jet on the man, it’s the man in the jet’
• Max explains the F/A-18’s helmet-mounted display gives a significant advantage for high off-boresight shots, while he believes the Su-57 lacks this capability
• Max describes the Su-57 as a ‘fourth gen plus’ fighter with some fifth-generation capabilities but essentially fourth-generation engines with thrust vectoring added
• Max recommends that when merging with a superior fighter like the Su-57, pilots should take aggressive high-angle gun shots early and commit to one-circle fights rather than extending range

Episode details: published February 19, 2023 · 59.2K views · 24:11 long. Summary written by Self Growth Videos from the episode itself. The analysis and commentary described are Max Afterburner’s, attributed to him — his channel includes hypothetical-scenario and news-react content, which is presented as his analysis, not established fact.

← Previous: Did The USA Shoot Down Objects from China’s Spy Program or hobby balloons? · Next: United Flight Plunges Towards Ocean →

All Max Afterburner videos · Max Afterburner profile · Max Afterburner on YouTube