Design Critique With RJ and Neil #1 | Are you doing it wrong? Reviewing the Top Selling POD Tshirts

About this video

In the first Design Critique episode, RJ Martinez and Neil from Merch Informer review Merch by Amazon designs live, starting with newest arrivals found via merchresearch.com. Neil explains that new listings take about a week to index and another week to gain visibility, so sellers should wait at least two weeks before changing titles or keywords; Amazon gives new products initial visibility, but clicks without purchases tell the algorithm to send traffic elsewhere. Critiquing a flat ‘just a girl who loves pitbulls’ design, they contrast it with a competing listing with 112 reviews that stands out through layered text, hearts, and a galaxy/tie-dye pattern — the difference is layout and a pattern overlay, not artistic talent. They stress that the title is the most important keyword field, warn against designing in niches you don’t understand (risking rejections and IP infringement), and note that auto-translated listings for the UK/German markets lose to native-language listings, though translation rejections don’t count against an account. A recurring tactic is doubling down: one seller reused a winning design with different filters, keywords, products, and prices ($18.99 standard, $16.99 premium, a hoodie) to add incremental monthly revenue. They advise studying top sellers’ techniques rather than copying designs — pointing to Disney niching down into Chinese New Year ‘year of the tiger’ (a search showing 122 results initially, about 410 by page three) — testing designs with a few dollars of ad spend, mining Pinterest for funny hobby sayings not yet on Amazon, and noting Neil’s joke ‘moist’ shirt sells every day because it is unique and makes people laugh.

Key takeaways

• Give new Merch by Amazon listings at least two weeks to index and gain visibility before changing keywords or titles
• Designs stand out through layout, layering, and pattern overlays — not raw artistic talent; flat text-plus-clipart loses to competitors
• The title is the most important keyword field; study top sellers’ title and bullet techniques without copying their designs
• Double down on winners: reuse a selling design with new filters, keywords, products, and price points under the same brand
• Test designs cheaply with a few dollars of ad spend, and mine Pinterest for funny sayings that don’t yet exist on Amazon

Episode details: published December 16, 2021 · 50:48 long. Summary written by Self Growth Videos from the episode itself. Business results and any income figures mentioned are RJ Martinez’s own claims, shared for education — they are not typical or guaranteed.

← Previous: Make Money Online With Merch By Amazon | Easy Side Hustle Ideas For Beginners 2022 · Next: KDP Low Content Hack | Sell More Books Faster With KDP Low Content Strategy 2022 | The Simple Way →

All RJ Martinez videos · RJ Martinez profile · RJ Martinez on YouTube