Etsy Just Put Every Digital Seller in a Test They Didn't Sign Up For

About this video

RJ Martinez reports on Etsy’s September 2026 seller update, reading Etsy’s wording aloud: Etsy is testing an experience that lets buyers turn eligible digital purchases into physical prints ‘sold, printed, and fulfilled by a third-party print on demand provider on Etsy,’ via a separate checkout, with the seller not responsible for producing or shipping. Crucially, he stresses, ’eligible sellers are included in this test automatically’ and can opt out anytime — no email was sent. He contrasts the economics using his own rough estimates: a $25 Comfort Colors shirt on Etsy leaves little after print cost and fees, while a $4.99 digital wall art file has no print cost, shipping, or damaged-item reships, and a bundle of three prints for $12.99 would keep around $11.31. He notes Etsy tried a version in 2022 that sent buyers off Etsy to outside providers, whereas this test keeps the sale on Etsy — but Etsy has not named the provider. His 10-minute starter plan: pick a niche that already buys wall art (he uses book lovers), generate text-free art in Ideogram (e.g. cozy reading nook, warm light, vintage illustration style, no text), add words later, fix dimensions, export a ratio pack of five files including 11 by 14 and the A series for international buyers, and deliver them zipped or in one PDF. He gives a price ladder of $4.99 for a single, $12.99 for a set of three, and $24.99 for a bundle, plus a new custom-options upsell charging $3 for personalized text. The catch he promised: the update does not identify the provider or explain whether the seller receives any additional payment from the physical print sale. His strategy is to stay in the test for now, price files as if he will never see a cent from prints, check shop settings weekly for the opt-out switch, disclose AI use in descriptions as Etsy asks, and convert existing shirt designs into printables for Q4.

Key takeaways

• Etsy’s September 2026 test auto-includes eligible digital sellers — buyers can order a third-party-printed physical version in a separate checkout, and sellers can opt out anytime
• Etsy has not named the print provider or said whether the original seller gets any payment from the physical print sale — that unanswered question is the central risk
• Digital math beats shirts in his rough estimates: a $4.99 file has no print/shipping/reship costs, and a $12.99 three-print bundle would keep around $11.31
• Starter workflow: generate text-free art, add words later, export a five-file ratio pack (including 11x14 and A-series sizes), price at $4.99 / $12.99 / $24.99, and add a $3 personalized-text upsell
• His play: stay in the test, price as if print revenue will never arrive, check settings weekly for the opt-out, disclose AI use, and convert existing shirt designs into printables for October-December gifting

Episode details: published September 26, 2026 · 9:05 long. Summary written by Self Growth Videos from the episode itself. Business results and any income figures mentioned are RJ Martinez’s own claims, shared for education — they are not typical or guaranteed.

← Previous: This Etsy Shop Didn’t Exist a Few Days Ago. It Cost $2 to Build. (AI Did Everything) · Next: This Etsy Shop Is 4 Months Old and Made $57K Last Month With One Template →

All RJ Martinez videos · RJ Martinez profile · RJ Martinez on YouTube