It's Too Late for Halloween. Here's What's Still Open.

About this video

The creator argues that Q4 print-on-demand success is a calendar problem, not an algorithm problem, citing Printify’s holiday guidance that demand peaks 24 to 32 days before a holiday. Speaking on October 6th, he says Halloween (October 31st) buying already peaked September 29th to October 7th, so new Halloween uploads land after buyers have left; sales sellers see now come from listings uploaded in September. He tells viewers to leave existing Halloween designs up for next year’s search history and to recycle concepts, for example turning a ghost into a gnome or spooky season into cozy season. Thanksgiving (November 26th) peaks October 25th to November 2nd and Christmas peaks November 23rd to December 1st, and because Etsy and Amazon need days to index and rank new listings, he says sellers are only truly live when the platform trusts the listing, so Thanksgiving listings must be up by October 20th and Christmas listings by November 15th. He calls Thanksgiving the most underpriced holiday because sellers skip straight to Christmas, and offers five angles beyond ’thankful, grateful, blessed’: Friendsgiving, food jokes such as ‘just here for the pie,’ family matching with family name and year, teacher Thanksgiving week shirts, and Thanksgiving football, recommending five Thanksgiving listings with the personalized family name plus year first because customization carries the margin. For Christmas he advises putting one design on a sweatshirt, a mug, and an ornament — three listings from one file — since sweatshirts sell in December and mugs and ornaments sell as gifts in multiples, with angles including family matching sets, pet parents, teachers, and funny in-law designs. He warns that orders after Printify’s shipping cutoff will not arrive before Christmas and the one-star review lands on the seller’s shop, so sellers should match Etsy processing times to real numbers, state ‘arrives after Christmas’ in the first line of the description after the cutoff, and check the fulfillment page weekly.

Key takeaways

• Demand peaks 24-32 days before a holiday, per Printify guidance he cites
• Thanksgiving listings live by Oct 20; Christmas listings live by Nov 15
• Leave Halloween designs up for next year but stop adding new ones
• Put one Christmas design on a sweatshirt, mug, and ornament
• After the shipping cutoff, state ‘arrives after Christmas’ in the description

Episode details: published October 8, 2026 · 7:29 long. Summary written by Self Growth Videos from the episode itself. Business results and any income figures mentioned are RJ Martinez’s own claims, shared for education — they are not typical or guaranteed.

← Previous: The Best Etsy Clothing Shops Aren’t Out-Designing You. They’re Using Better Blanks. · Next: I Found the Shop Behind Etsy’s New Print Test. It’s Worse Than Yours. →

All RJ Martinez videos · RJ Martinez profile · RJ Martinez on YouTube